PDA

View Full Version : Miller vs Prior chicagosports.com article


ryno4ever
Mar 7th 2007, 8:46 pm
Miller wades to forefront in arms race
Seizes early edge as Cubs' 5th starter

By Paul Sullivan
Tribune staff reporter

March 7, 2007, 8:12 PM CST

MESA, Ariz. -- With one start down and five to go, Wade Miller is the front-runner in his bid to capture the fifth spot in the Cubs rotation.

Just don't tell Miller.

"I've only had one outing," he said.

Coming into camp, it was believed the fifth starter's spot was Mark Prior's to lose. But after Prior's erratic outing Monday, he could be in danger of losing it.

Miller will face the Padres on Thursday in Peoria, Ariz., where Miller will try to show he's back from the shoulder surgery that curtailed his career in 2005. Miller is confident he can win the spot if he puts up numbers that show he's in form.

"If you pitch well enough or pitch better than what people are competing for, you should earn it," he said. "You have to go out there and earn it, no matter what you did before, no matter where you were at before."

After spending most of last season traveling in the Cubs' minor-league system on rehab assignments, Miller, 30, was 0-2 in five September starts. He re-signed in November for $1.5 million, paying back general manager Jim Hendry for giving him the chance in the first place.

"We signed last year for the long haul," Miller said. "I knew it wasn't going to be a full season or my strongest season. But we knew I was going to get better. Jim and I talked, and we both kept our word."

Manager Lou Piniella said Wednesday he'd like to open the season with 11 pitchers instead of 12, giving him an extra position player.

"I don't know if we can do that," he said. "Let's see what happens here. It depends on the starters, depends on the health of our bullpen. I like the idea of that extra guy on the bench."

If the Cubs carried only 11 pitchers, Miller or Prior would be in jeopardy because Neal Cotts, the other starter candidate, can be a reliever. The other four starting pitchers are assured of roster spots, as are relievers Ryan Dempster, Bob Howry, Kerry Wood, Scott Eyre and probably Will Ohman.

Prior, who is scheduled to pitch in relief Saturday, has received more attention than Miller, though Piniella insists there is no front-runner for the starting job. But Prior won't be given the spot if his performance doesn't improve, and some have criticized the Cubs for coddling him.

In a commentary last month on MSNBC.com, former Cubs pitcher and current Giants TV analyst Mike Krukow wrote: "Everywhere Prior has been, he has been babied because of his golden arm. The time for that to stop is now."

Krukow also ripped Prior's approach to hitters, saying: "He has been in a strikeout mode since he first put on a big-league uniform, and that means he nibbles early in the count and throws a lot of pitches. He needs to learn how to pitch in the big leagues, and primarily that means understanding the most effective use of the fastball with the two grips—going up and down and to both sides of the plate with it so it actually becomes four pitches. Once he does this, he will … explode."

In Prior's outing Monday, he threw first-pitch balls to eight of the nine hitters he faced and reached 40 pitches in 11/3 innings, walking two. Only one hitter swung at and missed a pitch.

The Prior who showed up Monday was in contrast to the pitcher's first four years in the majors, when he struck out 718 and walked only 195, an impressive strikeouts-to-walks ratio. Last year he struck out 38 while walking 28, nibbling around the corners instead of going directly at hitters.

Miller has followed a similar path, striking out 562 hitters and walking 259 from 2001-04 before shoulder surgery negated his fastball. While rehabbing with the Cubs last September, he struck out 20 and walked 18 in 211/3 innings. His fastball is still in the mid-80s, as Prior's was Monday.

"My fastball is coming around," Miller said. "I threw a bullpen [session] a couple of days ago, and I feel great right now."

If Miller doesn't earn the fifth spot, he said, "I'll have to explore my options." Going to the bullpen isn't among them, and Hendry likely would accommodate Miller if he asks for a trade.

"Until that time comes, I'm a Cub," Miller said.

Is that something we want? But what other choice is there? If they go with 11 pitchers, someone has to go..... Nice problem to have, but it could be a fork in the road with consequences at both ends.

CubsFan23
Mar 7th 2007, 8:50 pm
Maybe this will light a fire under Prior!

ChinMusic22
Mar 7th 2007, 8:53 pm
I guess Mike Krukow isn't a Mark Prior fan

I think after 1 game each it's too early to tell...

I know it sounds bad, but does anyone know if Prior has any options left? It's something Len mentioned today on the radio broadcast. IT would be a serious blow to Prior's ego, but if he is healthy and needs some work it could be a viable option.

BigZ38
Mar 7th 2007, 8:53 pm
It will cause competition between the two of them and they'll have to prove to Pinella who's better. Not a bad thing to have. Either would fill the spot nicely.

DLee25
Mar 7th 2007, 8:56 pm
When is the last time a club had a 6 man rotation?

I don't want one, I just thought it was good question. There had to be a time.

CubsFan23
Mar 7th 2007, 8:59 pm
I think Miller would complain less if he were put in the bullpen.

ryno4ever
Mar 7th 2007, 9:09 pm
I'm not sure when the last time the Cubs used a 6 man rotation on a consistent basis. That kind of rotation would really not be looked upon favorably by players and agents as a lot of their incentives are based on their performances and a six man rotation would really cut back on their opportunities.

DLee25
Mar 7th 2007, 9:10 pm
I'm not sure when the last time the Cubs used a 6 man rotation on a consistent basis. That kind of rotation would really not be looked upon favorably by players and agents as a lot of their incentives are based on their performances and a six man rotation would really cut back on their opportunities.

I agree, I know it's not used but I just thought it was an interesting question.

HOLYCOW!25
Mar 7th 2007, 10:04 pm
It would be really wierd seeing Prior in a different uniform. But if Miller wins the spot (not saying he will, just speaking hypotheticly because I think it's too early to predict) then I think that's the only real option.

TRIPLE PLAY
Mar 7th 2007, 10:17 pm
Maybe this will light a fire under Prior!

Change of scenery will help,i'm not conviced his 80 something M.P.H.golden arm has a home in Chicago,anymore-it sucks but reality HAS to sink in! good luck elsewhere-'cause it's inevitable in my 2 cents worth,SEE YA! hope we get something more for him than DA BEARS got for T.Jones!:mad:

ryno4ever
Mar 7th 2007, 11:42 pm
I think Miller would complain less if he were put in the bullpen.

If Miller doesn't earn the fifth spot, he said, "I'll have to explore my options." Going to the bullpen isn't among them, and Hendry likely would accommodate Miller if he asks for a trade.

"Until that time comes, I'm a Cub," Miller said.

I don't think he wants bullpen action. It sounds like if he doesn't get the starter spot, he will get traded before the season starts.

ryno4ever
Mar 7th 2007, 11:46 pm
You know, the Cubs can pull their old routine and find them suddenly hurt with a mysterious ailment and put them on the DL to make sure they made the right decision. Let's say Miller earns the spot, Prior gets put on the DL for smashing his fist into the locker (or kicking a fan, or pinching his pitching fingers in a folding chair giving him blisters, or sneezes and throws his back out, etc.), Miller goes out and does horrible. Prior's 15 days are up, Miller gets sent off, and Prior gets the 5th starter spot. Sounds all too familiar.

CubsFan23
Mar 8th 2007, 12:53 am
Let us pray it does not come to that!

HEYHEY
Mar 8th 2007, 8:30 am
Priors a leach to the organization.Its REALLY time to move on.Don't yous think.

champsx5
Mar 8th 2007, 9:55 am
When is the last time a club had a 6 man rotation?

I don't want one, I just thought it was good question. There had to be a time.

No team has ever used a 6 man rotation. In today's game, the 5 man rotation is pretty solid in terms of these pitcher, even the fifth guy, will start every five days, or every 5 games. When double headers pop up, an extra pitcher will get called up from the minors, and you have a temporary 6 man rotation.
Back in the old days, your number one pitcher was going to get the ball every 4-5 days, regardless. Coming out of Spring, teams would only carry 9 pitchers because they used 4 man rotations and sometimes that 4th guy wouldn't pitch for a week.

Ivy Killa
Mar 8th 2007, 10:21 am
It really sucks it has to come down to this.....of course theres no guarantee Prior will be healthy but still, the minute we signed Marquis i knew there was no way Miller would accept a bullpen spot and here we are now...another good pitcher wants out of town because theres no room for him...I really wanted to see this guy return to form.....now it will have to be in another uniform. I just read the Braves might be interested in him.....I can just see it now, Prior wont be 100% and Marquis will be less than average and then there will be miller, the guy we could have turned to, Pitching like he used to...but for someone other than the Cubs because we granted his trade request.....just like with Williamson. I wish hendry would just stick Marquis and his 7 mill in the bullpen right alongside Demp and his 4.5 - 5 mill and Howry and his 4 mill..........heres an idea, prolly wont work cause Miller doesnt want bullpen spot but......send Novoa down and keep Miller or Prior in the pen....a bullpen with Woody and Prior....now that would be ****e up, sorry people i'll stop rambling now.

CubsFan23
Mar 8th 2007, 3:30 pm
..........heres an idea, prolly wont work cause Miller doesnt want bullpen spot but......send Novoa down and keep Miller or Prior in the pen....a bullpen with Woody and Prior....now that would be ****e up, sorry people i'll stop rambling now.

That is what I have been saying all along. If Prior can't get his velocity back, then the pen maybe the thing for him. But hey its early and we are the Cubs, who knows what can happen. I personally do not care who pitches where right now just as long as we win the division in September!

BigZ38
Mar 8th 2007, 5:53 pm
I think Prior would take the idea of the bullpen better simply because he's been with the organization for a while and he wants to prove that he can contribute. On the other hand Miller would rather move on then be in the 'pen.